Safety

There is little safe about building any of the common types of massless speaker. You need to be very aware of the disadvantages of these transducers before you start any work on them. It is possible to address all of these safety issues and create a perfectly safe end product but it adds a lot to the difficulty of their design.

High Voltage

The most obvious disadvantage. Most plasma designs use quite high voltages - typically a few thousand and sometimes in the 10's of thousands of volts. Not only is there high voltage, but some designs also have the power available to deliver considerable current. If you don't know how to behave when working on high voltage circuitry do not attempt to build or use these devices. And you don't escape all safety concerns by using lasers to create the plasma instead.

With suitable insulation and screening having high voltage inside a product need not make it unsafe at all.  These speakers do need some access to the air in order to create sound, this open area can either be small and recessed enough to be untouchable or surrounded by a grounded metal mesh screen.

Toxic Gases

All plasma designs in air have the capacity to produce Ozone. Corona/ion wind designs using corona discharges are particularly efficient at producing it. Ozone is an invisible unstable form of oxygen (O3) which lasts around 20 minutes after being produced before breaking back down to O2. It smells quite refreshing, like a thunderstorm has been through the room, and is invisible. It is highly reactive and in high concentrations will degrade the cell walls of living things, including those in your lungs. An often quoted reference is that designer Nelson Pass successfully damaged his lungs when demonstrating his ion speaker and needed a visit to hospital.

As it is so reactive ozone can be readily catalysed back to O2.  Also if there is no oxygen present then no ozone is produced.

Ozone is the most commonly cited form of gas produced, but there is a much more toxic gas produced that is harder to detect and remove.

Plasma arcs, especially glow discharges, are very efficient at producing Nitrogen Oxides (the plasma combines the nitrogen and oxygen in the air), known as NOx and includes Nitrogen Oxide (NO) and Nitrogen Dioxide (NO2) (perhaps some less toxic Nitrous Oxide (N2O) as well). These are far worse than ozone.  NO2 is a brown gas with a harsh smell, but at lethal concentrations in air it is not visible and is odourless.

Amongst its effects are that it converts into nitric acid with the moisture of your lungs and eats them away, as well as entering the bloodstream and causing cancer. NOx is one of the emissions that is now restricted on car exhausts by using catalytic converters - you don't want it in your house.

The larger and more powerful the plasma arc, the more NOx is produced and in a small room the levels can build up quite quickly. You can't smell it or see it but it will stream upwards from a hot plasma. I have used a digital NOx meter to detect levels around a large plasma and it is off the scale above the plasma.  After 15 minutes concentrations in a small room are above safe levels. Designs like the Hill Plasmatronic used an inert gas to try and get around the gas problems, with no oxygen or nitrogen to combine together no NOx is produced.

Ultraviolet

The plasma arcs can emit ultraviolet light. It measures at a very low level, barely registering, on standard glow discharge plasmas with a UV light meter, even on a large arc there is far more UV from sunlight. On a high current arc discharge the UV levels can be dangerous in the same way as arc welding - causing burning of the retina and skin damage after long exposure.

X-Rays

High voltage sources can be used as X-ray emitters. However, there has to be very special circumstances, including specific electrodes and the use of a vacuum, for X-rays to be produced. I have also measured various forms of these speakers with a Geiger counter with no result, but it is something to keep in mind when working with voltages in the 10s of kV.

Safety
Types
Methods
Problems
Uses
 
 
Home
 
History
 
Design
 
Archive
 



©Copyright Adam Chambers 2024

Contact the Author

Cookie Policy

Plasma Speaker and Tweeter Ionophone Information

Plasma Loudspeakers

Ionovac and Plasmatronic

Plasma Tweeters

Plasma Speaker
Corona Wind or Ionic and Ion Speakers